This winery and wine shop located in Brooklyn's DUMBO area seems to have a good reputation among customers. Many reviewers have praised the friendly and knowledgeable staff, who are happy to offer recommendations and share their expertise. The store's selection of wines, including organic, natural, and biodynamic options, is also highly regarded. However, a few customers have mentioned that the staff can come across as unfriendly or arrogant at times. One reviewer mentioned feeling unwelcome in the store, which is concerning. On the other hand, many customers have appreciated the store's focus on supporting small, woman-owned wineries and its commitment to being a welcoming space for the LGBTQ+ community.The store's pricing seems to be a bit of a mixed bag, with some customers finding the prices to be reasonable and others feeling that they are too high. However, the overall consensus is that the store offers good value for the quality of the wines.The store's innovativeness is a strong point, with a focus on carrying unique and hard-to-find wines. The store's rotating selection and tastings also add to its appeal.Despite some minor issues, the overall experience at York Cellars seems to be positive, with many customers returning to the store and recommending it to friends. However, the store could benefit from improving its customer service and addressing any issues related to unfriendly staff.